Convicted cardinal makes demands over secretive pope election

Apr 24, 2025, updated Apr 24, 2025
Cardinal Giovanni Angelou Becciu has sparked controversy.
Cardinal Giovanni Angelou Becciu has sparked controversy.

A standoff is reportedly brewing at the Vatican as cardinals gather to hold the secretive conclave that will elect the next pope.

One cardinal, who was convicted of financial crimes and ordered to resign his top position by the late Pope Francis in 2020, is reportedly demanding to be allowed to take part.

Cardinal Giovanni Angelou Becciu, once one of the most powerful figures at the Vatican, is listed as a “non-elector”.

Becciu was previously the second-ranking official in the Vatican’s Secretariat of State and the pope’s de facto chief of staff.

But he was demoted after becoming embroiled in a financial scandal.

Becciu was the first cardinal to be convicted by the Vatican’s criminal court over alleged embezzlement, abuse of office and subordination of witnesses in 2023.

The case involved the church allegedly losing tens of millions of dollars investing in a London property.

He was sentenced to just over five years’ jail and is currently appealing.

Becciu is reportedly pushing for inclusion in the conclave and said the Holy See’s listing of him as a “non-elector” had no legal value.

He told L’Unione Sarda newspaper this week that the late pope had “recognised my cardinal prerogatives as intact”.

“There was no explicit will to exclude me from the conclave nor a request for my explicit renunciation in writing,” he said.

The secret meeting of cardinals, known as the conclave, usually begins between 15 and 20 days after a pope’s death.

Following the period of mourning, May 5 seems a likely date on which it might start.

The secretive inner workings of the process were dramatised in the 2024 Hollywood movie Conclave.

Starring Ralph Fiennes and Stanley Tucci, the film has shot up the Amazon Prime viewing list since the pope’s death on Easter Monday.

Only cardinals who were aged 80 or younger on the day of the Pope’s death have a vote.

While there must be a minimum of 120 cardinals in the conclave, there are about 135 cardinals of voting age.

The conclave convenes in the Sistine Chapel, where there can be up to four votes each day.

There is no set time for the conclave to elect a new pope, and if it carries on for a long time it is possible for the cardinals to take a break and have a non-voting day.

Pope’s body placed in basilica

Pope Francis

Cardinal Camerlengo Kevin Joseph Farrell spreads incense around the body of Pope Francis. Photo: AAP

The body of Pope Francis, laid out in an open coffin, has been carried in a solemn procession from his residence within the walls of the Vatican City to St Peter’s Basilica.

Red-hatted cardinals, bishops, candle-carrying friars and helmeted Swiss Guards walked slowly into the vast, sunlit square in front of the basilica as a choir chanted psalms and prayers in Latin while a bell gently tolled, as he was taken from the Vatican hotel where he live to the basilica.

The body of the 88-year-old pontiff, who died two days ago in his rooms at the Santa Marta guesthouse after suffering a stroke, was held aloft on a wooden platform by 14 white-gloved, black-suited pallbearers.

Stay informed, daily

As the coffin crossed St Peter’s Square, a crowd of several thousand broke into repeated applause – a traditional Italian sign of respect at such events.

Francis, who had only recently left hospital after five weeks being treated for double pneumonia, last appeared in public on Sunday, when he delighted onlookers gathered to celebrate Easter by being driven around the packed square in his white, open-topped popemobile.

Vatican officials rushed on Wednesday to help the pallbearers carry the coffin up a stone incline, before the procession passed through St Peter’s giant bronze doors and into the hushed interior of the ornate, cavernous church.

Francis’ body will lie in state in St Peter’s Basilica until Friday evening, allowing the faithful to pay their respects.

His funeral is set for Saturday and will draw heads of state and government from around the world, including US President Donald Trump, who clashed repeatedly with the pope on social issues such as immigration.

Leaders from Italy, France, Germany, Britain, Ukraine, Brazil, EU institutions and Francis’ home nation of Argentina have also confirmed their presence, among many others.

A conclave to choose the new pope is not expected to start before May 6.

The cardinals gathering in Rome will decide the date following what are often prolonged discussions.

There is no clear frontrunner to succeed Francis, who was from Argentina and was the first non-European pope in 1300 years, although British bookmakers have singled out Luis Antonio Tagle, a reformer from the Philippines, and Pietro Parolin, from Italy, as early favourites.

Tagle and Parolin stood together in the basilica, flanked by about 80 other cardinals, as the wooden coffin was laid on a dais in front of the altar, built on the spot where St Peter, the first pope, is believed to have been buried after dying as a martyr in the reign of Emperor Nero (AD54-68).

Francis’s body was dressed in red vestments, his hands clasped together holding a rosary, and a white mitre on his head.

Cardinal Raymond Burke, a US-born conservative prelate who was often at odds with Francis during his 12-year papacy, was among those who approached the coffin and bowed.

Francis shunned much of the great pomp and ceremony traditionally associated with the role of head of the world’s 1.4 billion Roman Catholics.

He clashed repeatedly with traditionalists, who saw him as overly liberal and too accommodating to minority groups, such as the LGBTQI community.

In electing a new pope, cardinals will have to consider whether to complete Francis’ promised reform of the Church, making more room for women in senior positions and being more amenable to an evolving society, or opt for retrenchment.

Some 135 cardinals are eligible to take part in the secretive conclave, which can stretch over days before white smoke pouring from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel tells the world that a new pope has been picked.

-with AAP

Just In